“I feel like I just ran a marathon!” my dad said as we stepped out into the blinding sun, stomachs grumbling. “Yeah, I think I held my breath every time we had to flee back to the ship before something ate us,” I said. Over lunch, we talked about the sheer expansiveness of the ocean against how intimate Anne Hathaway’s face felt in close-up, and agreed it was a beautiful film. Nolan’s choices lended a few genuinely new angles to a story we thought we already knew.
But this isn’t a movie review. What I realized was that I wasn’t just watching the trials but rather I was placing myself in them, before I’d consciously worked out why. Something in me knew the Cyclops before I could name what it was doing to my chest. It felt like my boss and the restrictions that he was trapping me in, yet at the same time I was aware I might’ve been suffering from my own single-mindedness. That’s the part that stuck. The monsters weren’t on the screen anymore by the time I got to the parking lot. They were in me.
That’s really what this myth is built on. Each monster is a piece of what Carl Jung would call the shadow self surfacing. This shadow self was something Odysseus has to face rather than out-run. He is guided as much by intuition and the gods whispering in his ear as by deliberate strategy. Athena shows up in disguise more than once just to nudge him toward what he already half-knew. These trials aren’t obstacles to conquer with logic alone. They’re invitations to listen to a wiser, quieter part of yourself that usually knows the way home before your conscious mind catches up.
So before you take the quiz below, try this instead of overthinking it. Read each option and notice which one lands in your body, not just your head. That flicker of recognition is the intuition doing its job. Trust it.
Part 1: Take the Quiz- Meet Your Shadow: Which Trial of The Odyssey Are You Living Right Now?
Answer instinctively. Tally which letter comes up most.
1. Right now, my biggest struggle feels like:
A) Someone (or something) in my life has one fixed way of seeing things, and there’s no reasoning with it.
B) I’m being pulled in two directions and any choice I make costs me something.
C) I keep noticing the same trait in myself around a certain person or place, and I don’t love what that says.
D) I’m haunted by the past.
E) There’s something I am afraid to examine alone.
F) I’m comfortable and safe, yet I still feel trapped.
G) I built a life around a version of myself that made sense once, and I’m not sure it still does.
2. When things get hard, I tend to:
A) Get tunnel-visioned and try to eliminate the problem.
B) Freeze, because every option seems to demand a sacrifice.
C) Let a certain environment bring out a side of me I don’t recognize anywhere else.
D) Replay old losses instead of dealing with what’s in front of me.
E) Keep busy so that I don’t have to sit with something heavy one my own.
F) Numb out and settle. It’s easier to stay comfortable than deal with what’s actually wrong.
G) Play the role I’ve always played, even when it stopped fitting a while ago.
3. The part of myself I’m most avoiding right now is:
A) My flexibility — I’m certain I’m right and unwilling to look at it another way.
B) My decisiveness — I keep waiting for a choice with no downside.
C) My sense of self — It’s fine most places, except around one person or situation I haven’t examined.
D) My grief — there’s a loss I haven’t let myself fully feel.
E) My baggage — I know it is there. I just don’t want to unpack it.
F) My drive — comfort has replaced any real ambition and I’ve stopped noticing the difference.
G) My identity — I don’t feel recognized for who I actually am anymore.
4. If a wise friend described your current state in one line, it might be:
A) “You won’t budge, even when the evidence says budge.”
B) “You’ve been stuck between two bad options for weeks now.”
C) “You don’t sound like yourself lately.”
D) “You keep bringing up the past in conversations about the present.”
E) “You act like something is weighing on you but you always change the subject before we actually get to it.”
F) “You’ve stopped trying because it’s just easier.”
G) “You’ve been so easy to predict lately. When’s the last time you surprised yourself?”
Scoring:
Tally up which letter you answered the most. Note: If you’re tied between two letters: don’t force a single answer — Odysseus rarely faced only one trial at a time either. Read both entries in Part 2. Usually one will describe what’s happening to you (the external situation) and the other will describe what’s happening in you (your internal response to it) — for example, a tie between Cyclops and Scylla & Charybdis might mean you’re dealing with someone rigid (external) while you’re paralyzed over how to respond (internal). Sit with both, and notice which one you resist reading more. That resistance is usually a clue to which one is actually running the show.
- Mostly A → The Cyclops (Polyphemus)
- Mostly B → Scylla and Charybdis
- Mostly C → Circe’s Mirror
- Mostly D → The Underworld
- Mostly E → The Sirens
- Mostly F → Calypso’s Island
- Mostly G → The Homecoming (Coming Home to Yourself)
Part 2: What Each Trial Represents
👁️ The Cyclops (Polyphemus) — Ego Without Reflection
One giant eye, one point of view, immense strength, zero capacity for nuance. In Nolan’s version, Cyclops barely speaks at all, sealed in his cave and blind to anything outside his own single view, blocking the only way out and daring anyone to try. Odysseus and his men get past him with patience and cunning, moving as a group instead of trying to reason with something that can’t be reasoned with. And yet, Odysseus still can’t leave it alone. He goes back to wound the blinded Cyclops again on the way out, provoking a threat he didn’t need to provoke. That’s actually the more precise Jungian read here. The Cyclops is the shadow, the raw, unexamined instinct we’d rather not recognize as ours. Odysseus is the ego, and his fatal flaw was never facing the Cyclops. It’s that he can’t resist one more act of pride even after he’s already won. Spotting tunnel vision in someone else is easy. Spotting it in yourself, when there’s nothing left to gain from being right, is the actual test.
🌊 Scylla and Charybdis — The Impossible Choice
A six-headed monster on one side, a ship-swallowing whirlpool on the other. No path through is without loss. This is the psychological experience of a true dilemma. Growth requires accepting a loss no matter what you choose. Jung saw this as central to psychological maturity. The ability to make a decision, sacrifice a piece of yourself, and grieve the road not taken is better than staying paralyzed between two forms of fear. When logic offers no clean answer, this is exactly the moment to drop into the body and ask what your gut already knows.
🐷 Circe’s Mirror — The Shadow Revealed
In Nolan’s version, Circe’s power is revealing what was already sitting underneath inside the men. Odysseus avoids his crew’s fate not because he’s protected, but because he stays outside long enough to notice something is wrong, before he ever sits down to that meal. That’s the real shift in this version. A place, a job, a relationship, a room full of a certain kind of people, none of it invents a trait in you from nothing. It loosens the grip on something that was already there, waiting for permission to come out. Jung would frame this as the environment acting like a mirror for the shadow rather than a cause of it. The practical question isn’t “what did this place turn me into?,” it’s “what did this place give me permission to stop hiding?”
💀 The Underworld — Confronting the Dead
Odysseus sails to the land of the dead to consult the prophet Tiresias, encountering the ghosts of his fallen comrades. Jung would call this a direct descent into the personal and collective unconscious. It’s the place where unprocessed grief, ancestral patterns, and unfinished business live. You don’t get useful guidance for the future until you’re willing to sit with what and who you’ve lost.
🎶 The Sirens — Seductive Self-Destruction
Homer’s Sirens tempt with omniscience, promising to tell Odysseus everything that’s happened and will happen in the world. Nolan’s version narrows that into something sharper and much more personal. In this telling, the song shows Odysseus every promise he’s failed to keep, and tells him he doesn’t actually want to go home at all. That’s a different threat than simple desire. It’s regret, and shame, and the parts of himself he’s been outrunning since Troy. Odysseus doesn’t skip the song. He insists on hearing it, bound to the mast, with people he trusts holding the rope so he can’t act on what it does to him. This is confronting the shadow’s harder material, guilt and broken promises, not alone in the moment it hits hardest, but inside a structure built by people who won’t let you go under. The temptation was never the real danger here. It’s that some truths about yourself are only feel safe to face with someone else’s support.
🏝️ Calypso’s Island — Comfortable Captivity
In Nolan’s version, this is where the lotus lives too. In this version, Calypso is the one feeding lotus flowers to Odysseus, keeping him hazy and detached from his own memory of home for years. Comfort and numbness aren’t two separate traps in this telling, they’re the same one. Calypso offers immortality, luxury, and her love if he’ll simply stay, and the lotus is what keeps him from ever clearly wanting to leave. This is the shadow of comfort: a captivity so pleasant, and so muddled, that it doesn’t register as captivity at all. Jung would frame this as stagnation disguised as safety, a refusal of the call to individuate because the current, smaller, softer life is simply easier. Underneath the haze, though, something in Odysseus keeps quietly surfacing anyway, flashes of memory breaking through, a homesickness of the soul that no amount of luxury or sedation can fully silence. That flicker is usually the surest sign it’s time to go.
🏠 The Homecoming — Reclaiming What’s Yours
When Odysseus finally reaches Ithaca, he doesn’t storm in. He arrives disguised as a beggar, unrecognized even by his own household, and has to slowly reassert who he is before he can reclaim his home from the suitors who’ve taken it over. The first ones to recognize him are his old dog and his loyal blind servant (devotion and instinct). They know him before his own mind has fully caught up to who he’s become. According to Jung, this is individuation’s final stage: not becoming someone new, but returning to a self you’d half-forgotten under everything your life’s journey put on top of it.
Part 3: How to Navigate Your Trial
Whichever trial you recognized yourself in, treat it less like a puzzle to solve and more like a signal to sit with. Odysseus made it home not because he outsmarted everything, but because he stayed close enough to his own intuition to know which fights were his to win.
Step 1 — Name what you’re actually facing
Say it plainly: “I am currently stuck in the comfort of what I know (Calypso’s island)” or “I’m being asked to choose between two impossible choices (Scylla and Charybdis).” Naming the trial pulls it out of vague anxiety and into a specific, workable shape.
Step 2 — Ask it direct questions
Address your trial face to face the way that Odysseus did:
- Cyclops: Where am I so certain I’m right that I’ve stopped listening?
- Scylla & Charybdis: What am I willing to lose in order to actually move forward?
- Circe: What does this particular environment/relationship keep giving me permission to do that I don’t do anywhere else?
- Underworld: Who or what haven’t I properly grieved?
- Sirens: What’s the truth about myself I can only really hear with someone else in the room?
- Calypso: What is comfort costing me? What am I focusing on so that I can avoid this?
- Homecoming: If I stopped performing the smaller version of myself for one day, what would come back first?
Step 3 — Journal it as dialogue
Write “Me:” and pose one of the questions above. Then write the trial’s answer without editing yourself. For example:
Me: Calypso, why won’t you let me leave? Calypso: Because out there, you might fail. In here, you’re safe and adored forever. Me: And what is that costing me?
This kind of unfiltered back-and-forth journaling, rooted in Jungian “active imagination”, surfaces what your rational mind edits out.
Step 4 — Check in with your gut before your strategy
Now that you’ve journaled about it, notice if any ideas have surfaced that can mark a path forward. But before you plan anything, sit quietly for a minute and ask your body, not your brain, one question: does this path feel like sailing toward something, or hiding from something? Odysseus’s real edge was never just cleverness — it was Athena, showing up as a hunch, a stranger’s advice, a feeling he couldn’t quite explain but trusted anyway. You don’t need a goddess. You just need to notice the quiet, physical difference between a decision that settles you and one that only distracts you.
Step 5 — Borrow Odysseus’s actual tactics
Each trial in the epic has a matching strategy, and they translate directly:
- Facing a Cyclops-boss or Cyclops-relative (someone rigid, certain, unwilling to see another view): Don’t confront it head-on with force. It will crush you. Odysseus escaped through patient, quiet cunning, not a shouting match. He waited, planned, and moved as a group instead of trying to out-argue the giant one-on-one. At work, this looks like proposing a small, low-risk pilot instead of demanding wholesale change. And take the second half of the lesson seriously too. Once you’ve actually won a round with your own Cyclops, resist the urge to make sure they know it. That extra dig is rarely necessary, and it’s usually your ego, not your judgment, asking for it. Facing your own inner Cyclops (when you’re the one with the single fixed view): This one’s harder to spot because it never feels like tunnel vision from the inside. It just feels like being right. A useful check is to notice when you’re more interested in winning a conversation than understanding the other side of it, or when “I’ve already thought about this” is doing the work of actually thinking about it again. Try deliberately arguing the opposing view out loud or on paper, even if you don’t believe it. Don’t do it to change your mind, but to confirm you still have two eyes and not one. If you can’t generate a decent version of the other side’s argument, that’s usually the sign.
- Facing your own Sirens (a truth about yourself you’ve been avoiding, not just a craving): In Nolan’s version, the Sirens don’t tempt Odysseus with pleasure, they confront him with every promise he’s broken and the shame of not wanting to go home at all. What actually helped Odysseus was hearing it inside a structure that could hold him while he listened, people who wouldn’t let him drown in it just because he begged. If there’s a regret or a piece of shame you’ve been keeping at a safe distance, don’t process it alone at 2am when it’s loudest. Bring it into a room with a therapist, a trusted friend, or someone steady enough to hear it with you and still keep you upright. That’s the mast. The rope is whoever’s willing to hold it.
- Facing Circe’s Mirror (an environment revealing a pattern rather than causing one): The skill Odysseus uses is watching before participating, noticing the deer-turned-man before he ever eats the meal. That means paying attention to patterns, not just moments. If a specific place, group, or role keeps “bringing out” the same trait in you, whether it’s an appetite, a temper, a laziness, or a cruelty, stop treating each instance as a surprise and start treating it as data. Ask what that particular environment reliably gives you permission to do that you don’t do elsewhere. Once you can name the permission, you have two real options: change what you let the environment give you access to, or change the environment. The same lens works looking at other people. When someone seems to “become someone else” around a certain influence, ask what got revealed and whether it keeps happening in the same conditions, because a repeated pattern tells you something a single incident never will.
- Stuck on Calypso’s island (comfortable, and quietly numb): In the film, the comfort and the haze are the same trap, since Calypso is the one feeding him the lotus that keeps him hazy in the first place. So to begin, you must clear the haze. Ask what “leaving” would actually cost you, answer honestly, and think about whether you’re overestimating that cost the way years on the island can make anyone overestimate the danger of the sea. And remember, Odysseus doesn’t get out through willpower alone. The clarity has to come first. It’s usually in the form of a memory or a flash of the life he actually wants breaking through the haze. Practically speaking, decide one small, non-negotiable move toward the thing you’re avoiding and let that one action clear a little of the haze before you try to plan the whole exit. For example, delete the social media apps on your phone so that instead of scrolling you actually take time to sit with the thoughts or feelings that you were avoiding. You might even download a meditation app instead and use that to help your true desires surface.
- In the Underworld (grieving something unresolved): Odysseus doesn’t get a straight answer from Tiresias until he’s spilled blood for the dead, grief before guidance, in that order. That order matters more than one would think. Most people try to skip straight to the useful part (what should I do now?) without ever actually sitting with what was lost, and then wonder why the same ache keeps interrupting decisions that have nothing to do with it. Try giving it a designated visit instead of letting it ambush you at random moments. Make a specific time to write to, or about, what you’ve lost, so it stops leaking into everything else. Say what you’d say if they were across the table. The point isn’t closure in one sitting. It’s that grief given a scheduled seat at the table tends to stop showing up uninvited everywhere else.
- Reaching your Homecoming (coming home to a self you’d half-forgotten): Argos knew Odysseus before anyone else did. Not because Odysseus proved anything, but because devotion doesn’t need proof, it recognizes on instinct. That’s the practical part worth stealing here. Instead of trying to argue your way back into an old boundary or an old version of yourself, pay attention to who already responds to the real you the moment a little of it resurfaces, no explanation required. Make a short list: the person who still laughs at the version of your humor you’d quieted down, the friend who asks about the hobby you dropped like it never left, the family member who never bought the smaller act you’d been putting on. Those responses are your Argos. But the same instinct works from the inside too, and it’s usually quieter. Notice the moments something in you relaxes without you deciding to, a laugh that comes out before you’ve filtered it, a memory that surfaces uninvited and feels more like relief than nostalgia, a “yes, that” reaction to an old photo or an old song you can’t quite explain. That’s the same recognition Argos had, just aimed at yourself. Spend time in both places, the people who already know you and the moments you catch yourself knowing it too, before you try to reclaim ground with anyone who’s grown used to the quieter version of you.
What to Remember on the Way Out
Odysseus never beat a single trial through force alone. He had Athena in his ear, gut instinct in his chest, and just enough humility to listen to both. That’s the part the logical self often skips. Sometimes the way through isn’t a smarter plan, but a quieter mind. When I sit across from my own Cyclops-boss now, I’m not just strategizing, I’m paying attention to the moment that feels right to speak up, and the moment that says wait. That instinct is worth as much as any tactic or strategy.
You’re not lost. You’re just between islands and something in you already knows which way to sail.
Spiritual Direction and Healing Touch Energy Therapy 